NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
Re: On polar nav
From: Walter Guinon
Date: 2002 Sep 11, 18:16 -0700
From: Walter Guinon
Date: 2002 Sep 11, 18:16 -0700
Is the behavior of a pendulum a useful indication of nearness to the pole? --- Peter Foggwrote: > Am reading 'Robert E. Peary at the North Pole' A Report to the National > Geographic Society by The Foundation for the Promotion of the Art of > Navigation. > > It has, not unexpectedly, much data on the navigation involved. There is > a map showing his track, which indicates he over-ran his latitude by a > few miles (kept going north until he was heading south again) and the > implication is that this ensured he reached the pole, given the > limitations of his instruments - within about 5 miles. > > This raises a question, which was put as an assertion by a 'reliable > source' - that the thing to do, and the thing done, was to set out from > the polar camp and follow a circle around it, so that the actual pole, > if a little way off, would be encompassed and any subsequent doubts > about exact postion would > be laid to rest. The book doesn't mention this, although the track on > the map indicates Peary was off a little to one side (to the left while > facing north). > > Some time ago there was some discussion on the list about polar > navigation. Amundsen apparently camped and measured the sun's altitude > thoughout the day. Although I have no reason to doubt that these > measurements were taken with great care surely there would be a > practical limit to just how precise a spot they could indicate. > > Does anybody know whether Amundsen did send out a party to circle his > polar camp? I know Scott found Amundsen's black tent and accepted this > as the pole, so I guess he didn't describe any circles. __________________________________________________ Yahoo! - We Remember 9-11: A tribute to the more than 3,000 lives lost http://dir.remember.yahoo.com/tribute