Welcome to the NavList Message Boards.

NavList:

A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding

Compose Your Message

Message:αβγ
Message:abc
Add Images & Files
    or...
       
    Reply
    Transit time at Greenwich, England 4-5 seconds different from my meridian.
    From: Jim Thompson
    Date: 2003 Dec 22, 08:48 -0400

    I will lay out my problem, and then ask two questions.  This relates to my
    post yesterday where I quote Bowditch's section 2010 method for predicting
    meridian transit.
    
    Since the daily pages of the Almanac only give Meridian Passage to the
    nearest minute, then I calculated the precise time of meridian passage at
    Greenwich to the nearest second using the GHA and EqT methods, and then used
    those more precise times to predict the sun's transit time at my meridian
    (63o 08.0'W) using the method described in Bowditch section 2010.
    
    The answer for my meridian should be ZT 12h 08m 09s, according to the
    calculations described at
    http://jimthompson.net/boating/CelestialNav/NoonSunSight.htm
    
    If I use Method 1 (GHA method) to calculate transit time at Greenwich on
    September 14, 2003 to the nearest second, then this is what I get:
    1. GHA = 000o 00.0' .
    2. GHA next lower on that date = 346o 04.6' at whole hour GMT of 11h
    3. DLo = 13o 55.4' => 55m 42s .
    4. => Transit time at Greenwich = 11h 55m 42s, which agrees with the
    Almanac's 11h 56m.
    
    But even if I use that more precise time of meridian passage to estimate
    transit at my Lo of 63o 08.0'W, ignoring DST, then I still get a different
    answer using Method 2 (Bowditch section 2010), albeit much closer than
    before:
    
    5. Transit time at Greenwich = 11h 55m 42s = Transit time at my zone's
    central meridian (60o 00.0'W).
    6. Add that to DLo 03o 08.0' or 00h 12m 32s.
    7. => Transit time at my meridian =  12h 08m 14s, so something is still
    wrong here, because the answer I got for my meridian using the GHA method
    was 09 seconds, not 14 seconds.
    
    8. Alternatively, using the EqT method, since EqT = 4m 19s at 1200 (Almanac)
    then I would have expected transit to occur at Greenwich at a mean time of
     12h 00m 00s
    -00h 04m 19s
    --------------
    =11h 55m 41s, which also rounds to 11h 56m, and so also agrees with the
    Almanac's 11h 56m.  Note this time is 1 second different from that estimated
    by the GHA method.
    
    9. And if I use that time (11h 55m 41s ) for meridian passage, then of
    course I get
     11h 55m 41s
    +00h 12m 32s
    --------------
    =12h 08m 13s for meridian transit at my longitude.  But that's wrong too,
    because the answer should be 09 seconds, not 13 seconds.
    
    The two methods predict sun transit time at Greenwich 1 second different
    from each other, which I presume must be due to rounding.  Or perhaps it has
    to do with interpolating EqT.  By interpolation EqT is 0.8 seconds smaller
    at GMT 1100 than GMT 1200, but because the result is closer to 1200 I used
    EqT 04m 19s rather than EqT 04m 18s, which would have given a transit time
    of 11h 55m 42s in agreement with the GHA method, but I cannot see the logic
    in using EqT for 1100 rather than 1200.
    
    I posted a time diagram of the situation as I understand it at
    http://jimthompson.net/boating/CelestialNav/NoonSunSight.htm
    about halfway down the page, where all the above text is highlighted in
    yellow.
    
    My questions:
    
    1. Why are these estimates of transit time at my meridian different by 4-5
    seconds from the answers I got by the other methods posted at that webpage?
    2. Why do the daily pages of the Almanac give time of Meridian Passage to
    the nearest minute, rather than the nearest second?  Because it assumes that
    the navigator only needs an estimate of transit time to an accuracy of +/- 1
    minute?
    
    Jim Thompson
    jim2{at}jimthompson.net
    www.jimthompson.net
    Outgoing mail scanned by Norton Antivirus
    -----------------------------------------
    
    
    

       
    Reply
    Browse Files

    Drop Files

    NavList

    What is NavList?

    Join NavList

    Name:
    (please, no nicknames or handles)
    Email:
    Do you want to receive all group messages by email?
    Yes No

    You can also join by posting. Your first on-topic post automatically makes you a member.

    Posting Code

    Enter the email address associated with your NavList messages. Your posting code will be emailed to you immediately.
    Email:

    Email Settings

    Posting Code:

    Custom Index

    Subject:
    Author:
    Start date: (yyyymm dd)
    End date: (yyyymm dd)

    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site