Welcome to the NavList Message Boards.


A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding

Compose Your Message

Add Images & Files
    Re: Saturn Lunar by DSLR Camera
    From: Antoine Couëtte
    Date: 2017 Sep 30, 03:30 -0700

    re : Rudzinski-sep-2017-g40199 and Couëtte-sep-2017-g40210

    Hello Greg,

    I have been reworking your recent Saturn Lunar with http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html through successive iterations as described in Couëtte-sep-2017-g40210 :

    1 st result

    From your Distance = 2°36.4' , get Error in Lunar -0.2', Approximate Error in Longitude 5.1' , translating more accurately into Error in Lunar = -10.2".

    Let's remove this error, i.e. subtract (-10.2") from our initial 2°35.4' distance and run the whole computation again.

    Note : For the upcoming successive iterations only the sextant distance itself needs to be corrected onto http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html :

    2 nd result

    Starting with 2°36.4' - (- 10.2") = 2°36.570', get : Error in Lunar 0' (no sign given here), Approximate Error in Longitude 01.1', translating more accurately into Error in Lunar = +/- 2.2 " (since no sign given earlier). Let us assume that the " - " sign is still the correct one.

    3 rd result

    Starting again from 2°36.570' - (-2.2") = 2°36.610' , get : Error in Lunar 0', Approximate Errtor in Longitude 0.2', translating more accurately into Error in Lunar = +/- 0.4" .

    Let's continue keeping the " - " sign and start from 2°36.610' - (-0.4")  = 2°36.617' . We finally obtain :Error in Lunar 0', Approximate Error in Longitude 0.0' .

    Bingo ! :-)

    Discussion :

    1 - The final result of http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html obtained through 2 iterations is : 2°36.617' . It is 0.217' distant from your early value of 2°36.4'. Therefore the initially displayed " Error in Lunar -0.2' " statement is 100% right.

    2 - This most recent Saturn Lunar of yours is a good example of a short distance Lunar - less than 3° - where http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html immediately yields the right result. On the other hand for the recent Regulus occultation ( Couëtte-sep-2017-g40210 ) its first displayed result ( -0.8' Error at sea level ) - was off by 2.2' and totally unreliable. The actual value was slightly over 3.0' as also independently confirmed in Hirose-sep-2017-g40222 until now. Eleven subsequent manual iterations - of the kind demonstrated here-above - ran onto http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html yielded a final result within of few arc seconds of the results listed in Hirose-sep-2017-g40222 .

    3 - Last but not least, this systematic iteration method - although not necessary for this specific short distance Saturn Lunar - is an excellent and easy way to get the most out of http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html . Let's us simply hope that it can be simply implemented in "automatic mode" through limited software modification to the currently existing v4 version.

    Frank - who must be overloaded day and night with the preparation of his upcoming NavList Symposium - hopefully will have time to look into it in some near future.

    Thanks to all for your Kind Attention, to you Greg especially for your on-going excellent contributions. And also :

    Warmest thanks in advance to you Frank, if you can find time to "upgrade" http://reednavigation.com/lunars/lunars_v4.html which - again - is already a fabulous tool you invented for our greatest satisfaction and interest.


    Browse Files

    Drop Files


    What is NavList?

    Join NavList

    (please, no nicknames or handles)
    Do you want to receive all group messages by email?
    Yes No

    You can also join by posting. Your first on-topic post automatically makes you a member.

    Posting Code

    Enter the email address associated with your NavList messages. Your posting code will be emailed to you immediately.

    Email Settings

    Posting Code:

    Custom Index

    Start date: (yyyymm dd)
    End date: (yyyymm dd)

    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site