Welcome to the NavList Message Boards.


A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding

Compose Your Message

Add Images & Files
    Fwd: Medieval Astronomical Instruments
    From: Brian Whatcott
    Date: 2002 Jun 27, 06:03 -0500

    I am relaying David's note on Rete as germane to readers of
    History of Astronomy, and the Navigation list, I expect.
    Brian Whatcott
    >From: Kingabumax@aol.com
    >Date: Thu, 27 Jun 2002 06:30:06 EDT
    >To: "Rete" 
    >To colleagues in the History of Science, Medieval Islamic
    >Studies, Medieval European Studies, and the History of
    >Scientific Instruments ...
    >Subject: Medieval Islamic and European Astronomical Instruments
    > From Prof. David A. King
    >Institute for History of Science
    >Johann Wolfgang Goethe University
    >D 60054 Frankfurt am Main
    >em: king@em.uni-frankfurt.de
    >or: kingabumax@aol.com
    >Tel. +49-69-7982-2754 / -2337 / -2338
    >Fax: -3275
    >Dear Colleagues,
    >There is now an updated website giving information about
    >research on medieval Islamic and European astronomical
    >instruments that has been conducted in Frankfurt over the
    >past 10 years.
    >Some of this activity has been made possible by generous
    >support from the German Research Foundation (DFG).
    >The new website features a list of publications, works in
    >press, and works in preparation by members of the Frankfurt
    >team, past and present. In these publications we have tried
    >to use astronomical instruments as historical sources within
    >their cultural and geographical contexts. Thus, for example,
    >it was possible to show that the astrolabe supposedly dedicated
    >by Regiomontanus to his patron Cardinal Bessarion in 1462
    >but branded fake, was one of close to a dozen from the same
    >or closely-related workshops, some even by the same maker.
    >Again, it has been possible  to show that various medieval
    >European instruments such  as the quadrans vetus were known
    >already in 9th-century Baghdad.  In the case of the elusive
    >navicula de Venetiis we have been able to show that all of
    >the components were known in the same milieu, as was a
    >more complicated instrument for timekeeping by the stars
    >for any latitude. New evidence from manuscripts establishes
    >the context of three brass world-maps from 17th-century
    >Iran bearing hightly-sophisticated grids preserving direction
    >and (the sine of) the distance to Mecca at the centre firmly in
    >earlier (10th and 11th century) Islamic mathematics. Some
    >of the studies concentrate on the  inscriptions (such as
    >names of the zodiacal signs and months in regional Latin or
    >local vernaculars), the geographical information explicit or
    >implicit on instruments, and others treat the instruments
    >within the general context of astronomical timekeeping or
    >as historical works of art.
    >There is also provisional table of contents (TOC) of the catalogue
    >that has been in preparation for the past few years. This TOC can
    >serve for the  present and immediate future as an ordered list of
    >instruments, arranged chronologically by provenance. I would
    >be grateful for information on any early instruments that are
    >not listed here.
    >The information on instruments from after ca. 1500 was compiled
    >about 10 years ago and in the main has not been touched since.
    >The entries for such instruments in the TOC for later instruments
    >have simply been picked up by the automatic TOC generator:
    >for many of them there are no descriptions, and none are planned.
    >Certain later sections of the catalogue/TOC have been made
    >redundant anyway by recent publications by Gerard Turner (English
    >Renaissance), Koenraad van Cleempoel (Flemish and Spanish
    >Renaissance), and the forthcoming publication by S. R. Sarma
    >(Indian instruments with inscriptions in Arabic-Persian-Sanscrit).
    >The descriptions of instruments from before ca. 1500 are in
    >reasonable shape but are not yet publishable.  The long-term
    >goal was/is to make the descriptions available, starting with
    >early Islamic instruments (to 1200) and then the earliest
    >European instruments. This will be done in small batches, and
    >some sample descriptions will eventually be put on this site.
    >For the rest there is still plenty of work to be done.
    >Any serious researcher  working on a specific group of
    >instruments is welcome to inspect the materials available here
    >or take over the descriptions of such a corpus of instruments.
    >A major problem is the lack of adequate photographic
    >documentation. Only a minority of museums are capable of
    >preparing decent photos of instruments, and costs have
    >skyrocketed. See the site EPACT mentioned below for some
    >good photos.
    >More serious problems are: 1) the fact that funding for
    >the project is virtually exhausted, and 2) the fact that most
    >of the young scholars who  have been trained here in
    >the study of instruments have moved on.
    >The website is:
    >I hope that it will stimulate some serious interest in these
    >"forgotten treasures of the Middle Ages”.
    >Yours sincerely,
    >David A. King
    >IMPORTANT:   The website
    >EPACT: Scientific Instruments of Medieval and Renaissance Europe.
    >provides illustrations and descriptions of European instruments
    >in Oxford, Florence, London (BM) and Leiden
    Brian Whatcott
       Altus OK                      Eureka!

    Browse Files

    Drop Files


    What is NavList?

    Join NavList

    (please, no nicknames or handles)
    Do you want to receive all group messages by email?
    Yes No

    You can also join by posting. Your first on-topic post automatically makes you a member.

    Posting Code

    Enter the email address associated with your NavList messages. Your posting code will be emailed to you immediately.

    Email Settings

    Posting Code:

    Custom Index

    Start date: (yyyymm dd)
    End date: (yyyymm dd)

    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site