NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
Re: [Fwd: [Fwd: Davis Sextants]]
From: Bob Trenkamp
Date: 1999 Jan 25, 21:00 EST
From: Bob Trenkamp
Date: 1999 Jan 25, 21:00 EST
At 05:08 PM 1/25/99 -0800, John Brenneise wrote: >Has anyone subjected any of the sextants to which this thread of >discussion refers to a test of thermal expansion issues? Yep - when you leave a MK-3 on the coachroof for an hour at midday, you have to recompensate for index error. >Have any other quantitative measurements been made? #1: experiments with a binary result - it gets me where I've been trying to go. #2: experiments with a somewhat continuous result - from a fairly-stable deck just south of Long Island, I seem to have gotten a quasi-normal distribution of error (wrt the Loran readings) from LOPs, with the mean at 1.2 miles, std dev = .3 mi. (I just checked the log on this & did a quickie on excel, but I'm not about to go back through my log and crunch all the data. My sense is that this particular experiment yielded somewhat typical results. #3: experiments in the real world offshore - I just checked a few old plotting sheets and it seems that I generally get a cocked hat with a max dimension of 2-3 miles offshore. The LOPs used to construct the cocked hat are usually a mixture of advanced LOPs and current observations, though occasionally I can get 2 stars to mix with the moon. >There also is a practical issue of the mass of the sextant when >trying to take a sight from the deck of a pitching and rolling boat. Amen. >In practice, what precision do the MK15 et. al. deliver? >With my Astra IIIB and an artificial horizon consisting of >plate of oil placed upon the south facing deck (of my >condominium), I was able to get a fix that landed within >four nautical miles of that reported by my hand held GPS Wow, John...have you considered changing your oil...or perhaps your GPS batteries? (grin) Last time I used an Astra III, it beat my MK-3 by a long shot. It's weight made all the difference in trying to get good shots from a 38' sailboat. At the same time, I'd not be willing to part with the extra money to get that improvement. (Ritual and reverence are two separate concepts, please.) Regards, bob =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-= =-= TO UNSUBSCRIBE, send this message to majordomo@XXX.XXX: =-= =-= navigation =-= =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=