A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
From: Tom Sult
Date: 2016 Dec 05, 09:26 -0600
Tom Sult, MD
On Dec 5, 2016, at 01:58, David C <NoReply_DavidC@fer3.com> wrote:
Whle mowing the lawns this afternoon I noticed that the sun was visible more often than it was hidden by cloud. I checked a phone app and at my location the sun would be on the prime vertical at 1716 NZDST (-13). I looked at my watch and it was 1645. Clearly a double altitude sight was in order.
I took three pairs of sights. Unfortunately about 10 min before the sun was due west the sun disappeared behind a cloud. The cloud cover was such that I decided to put my sextant away. Then I noticed a blunder in the first pair of sights so I was left with two pairs of sights.
When I analysed the sights I discovered that the approximate formula cos lat = a/15/t is so sensitive to errors in time as to make it useless. It is possible that I have made an arithmetical error but I found that a four second error in three minutes gives an change in lat of nearly 1 °. It is many many years since I studied differential calculus so I doubt I could work out d lat/d t for the above formula.
Here is what I did:
I observed the sun in an AH. I noted the times when the bottom and top limbs touched and then when the top and bottom limbs touched. That is a change of two diameters but I am using an AH so the actual change is one diameter or 32.4'.
To check the accuracy of the sights I worked the first sight of each pair as an intercept and then as a time sight (with gps lat). I then used the formula cos lat = a/15/t to determine the lat by double altitudes. The intercept was worked with the cos formula, a calculator and the ABC tables. The time sight was worked by calculator.
GPS position S41° 06.5' E175° 05.2'
Zone -13 (NZDST)
Zone date 2016/12/5 (what is preferred time format for this forum?)
Ho 39° 39.4'
Time 1 165504
Time 2 165754
Intercept 0.2' A
Az N 85.7 W
Long by Chron 175 5.0'
Ho 38° 35.9'
Time 1 170037
Time 2 170331
Intercept 0.7' A
Azimuth N 86.5 W
Long by Chron 175° 6.1'
The change in altitude is 32.4 * 60 arc seconds
The time interval is 170 secs for the first pair and 174 sec for the second pair.
These numbers give 40° 19' and 41° 51' for the lat. What I find interesting is not the error in lat but just how sensitive lat is to the time interval.
Have I made a blunder?