A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
From: Brad Morris
Date: 2018 Nov 20, 08:54 -0500
SteveThere is no "rule" in today's world. Most computations are done digitally (electronically). For that reason alone, computations are done in pure decimal degrees. The conversions back and forth are done simply for the convenience of the user.The one tricky bit is the conversion with negative values, particularly with spreadsheets. With a little bit of care, however, there is no concern. Just assure yourself that the conversion is functional.On the otherhand, if you are converting back and forth manually, then in my view, this is very error prone. More so, in my opinion, than sexagesimal arithmetic of addition and subtraction. The conversions use multiplication and division. Perhaps you can do these conversions in your head, but I cannot.BradOn Mon, Nov 19, 2018, 12:55 AM Steve E. Bryant <NoReply_Bryant@fer3.com wrote:
When performing calculations involving degrees and minutes, I much prefer converting the minutes to degrees, proceeding with the additions and subtractions, and then converting the decimal degrees back to minutes.
There may be some statistical reason for not doing it that way; or, is the practice perfectly acceptable.
There are those professionals who teach navigation that insist upon working only with degrees and minutes, unless it's necessary to use decimal degrees for calculator entry in which case they carry the decimal out to the fifth place.
What are the rules, if any, that make the degree/minute conversions unacceptable; and, if there are prohibitions against the practice, is there anything one can do in the process that will statistically justify the conversions?