
NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
Civility
From: Robert Eno
Date: 2006 May 23, 11:51 -0400
From: Robert Eno
Date: 2006 May 23, 11:51 -0400
Folks, I have noticed over the past few months, that a certain amount of personal "slagging" has been going on. I am not the moderator, nor the owner, nor the founder of any of these sites so I am not trying to act as the site sheriff, however, as a participant of many years, I'd like to remind all that we should treat each other with respect and avoid personal attacks and "catty" comments. There are ways to disagree -- even vehemently -- with another list member without resorting to jaded inferences, pendantic reprovals and open hostility. If you think someone is full of ***t, fine, but try to articulate your sentiments with academic and polite rebuttals. Frank Reed seems to have been the focus of a few "off" comments. I don't believe for a minute that he is trying to subvert the old list and replace it with a new one under his control. Frank perceived that there is a serious problem with the old list and attempted to do something about it. Personally -- and this is only because I am not as computer savvy as most folks -- I did not see any major problems with the old site, other than periods of radio silence and the occasional delayed/lost messages, however that does not mean that there is not a problem. I lament the passing of the old list because it is the one I first signed onto and through it, I have met some fascinating folks. But Dan Hogan is moving on, no one seems to want to step in and take over the old list and Frank has offered us an alternative. At the end of the day, whoever doesn't want to go along with Frank, is free to go elsewhere or take over NAV-L. I agree with a few others that the club will remain the same; we are only meeting at a different place. Is it really that big a deal? I will continue to patronize both sites until this is sorted out or until the old list sails off into the sunset. Either way, I still get the benefit of some informative and interesting discussion. So please gents, let's try to be civil to one another and keep this list - wherever it may be - friendly and collegial. Robert