NavList:

   

Reply

Gordon,

I agree -- I am also very happy with the worn and doodled old copies
that cost only $50 to $100 or so.  I don't need the collectors' fine
editions.

I have both Norie and Bowditch, and I find Norie a little easier to
read.  Norie was Enlish I believe and Bowditch was American, so some of
the enthusiasm regarding Bowditch might be that this was one of the
first navigation texts written by an American that was widely
distributed.  Although I am American, I prefer my old Norie ...

Regards,
Bill Allen

-----Original Message-----
From: Navigation Mailing List
[mailto:NAVIGATION-L@LISTSERV.WEBKAHUNA.COM] On Behalf Of Gordon Talge
Sent: Friday, January 31, 2003 8:13 PM
To: NAVIGATION-L@LISTSERV.WEBKAHUNA.COM
Subject: 1851 Bowditch


I have bought three or four old navigation books off of www.abe.com
bookstores.

A 1798 John Hamilton Moore "New Practical Navigator", an 1807 Andrew
Mackay, "Complete Navigator, and an 1844 J.W. Norie, "A Complete Epitome
of Practical Navigation". None of them were super expensive. Why?
Binding warped, page missing, a page torn, title page ripped out ( 1798
More ) and so on.

The books that run $1,000 to $5,000 are no doubt in top condition, or
owned by somebody famous. ( Long John Silver's Nav book ) or something.

My books are completely readable and it is really kind of fun seeing how
they worked out their nav problems. Trig is introduced in an equivalent,
but entirely different way then modern texts. The change came about
between 1850 or 60 and 1910 or so.

It is also a real kick to look at the doodles and notes some one made
over 150 to 200 years ago.

On one of the blank pages in the Moore book, someone wrote a short verse
and signed it, "Carpenter of the J. Henary ( or Henry not sure ), John
Newbrums ( or Newborn ? ) 1806.

I am not use to reading that fancy old hand writing, but it is really
cool. I wish people wrote like that today.


Bowditch, is no doubt the most famous of the old navigation books. And
for the name alone it would command a higher price, but I don't know if
it is really any better than Mackay or esp. Norie.

I found out that they borrowed to put it nicely from each other. Tables,
problems, and so on.

All three books have a "Journal of a Voyage from London to Madeira and
Teneriffe" as a kind of "Final Exam". I think Bowditch does too.

-- Gordon

--
                              ,,,
                             (. .)
+-------------------------ooO-(_)-Ooo------------------------+
| Gordon Talge WB6YKK               e-mail: gtalge@pe.net    |
| Department of Mathematics       http://www.lbusd.k12.ca.us |
| Wilson High School                  Long Beach, CA         |
| (o-    Debian / GNU / Linux                                |
| //\    The Choice of the GNU Generation                    |
| v_/_                  .oooO                                |
|    - E Aho Laula -     (  )   Oooo. - Wider is Better -    |
+-------------------------\ (---(  )-------------------------+
                           \_)  ) /
                               (_/

   

Reply